In short: tequila is made only from blue agave and is usually steamed; mezcal can be made from more than 40 types of agave and is traditionally cooked in wood-fired earth ovens, which gives it its smoky character. Both are agave spirits with protected designations of origin, but mezcal is always 100% agave and is produced mainly in Oaxaca.
Is all tequila mezcal? Does all mezcal taste smoky? These are the two questions we get asked most at every tasting. The short answer: both come from agave and Mexico, but they are as different as a Loire wine and a sherry. Here are the real differences, myths aside.
In a nutshell
| Tequila | Mezcal | |
|---|---|---|
| Agave | Only blue agave (Agave tequilana Weber) | More than 40 species: espadín, tobalá, cuishe… |
| Region | Jalisco and some municipalities in Guanajuato, Michoacán, Nayarit, and Tamaulipas | Oaxaca (by far the largest share) and other states such as Guerrero, Durango, Zacatecas, San Luis Potosí, Puebla, Michoacán, Guanajuato, and Tamaulipas |
| Cooking | Masonry ovens or autoclaves (steam) | Traditionally in wood-fired earth ovens with volcanic stones |
| % agave | Minimum 51% | Always 100% agave |
1. Agave: one species versus dozens
Tequila is made from a single variety: blue agave. Mezcal can be made from dozens of different agaves. Espadín is the most widely grown and the most balanced; tobalá is wild, small, and has floral and fruity notes; cuishe adds a drier minerality. That is why two mezcals can taste as different from each other as a tequila and a whisky.
Patience also counts: an espadín agave needs years in the ground before it can be harvested, and tobalá can take even longer. At Ramo de Rosas, our 8-year-old espadín won recognition as the best espadín from Oaxaca at the Brussels World Contest.
2. Cooking: where the smoke comes from
This is the difference you can smell most. In artisanal mezcal, the agave hearts are cooked in a buried conical oven, covered with earth, and placed over firewood and hot stones for several days. This contact with the firewood is what gives it its smoky character. In industrial tequila, the hearts are usually cooked with steam in ovens or autoclaves, which gives them a cleaner, sweeter profile.
3. Milling and fermentation
Artisanal mezcal is milled by hand or with a tahona (a large stone wheel pulled by a horse or powered by a motor). Fermentation takes place in wooden vats, outdoors, using natural yeasts. In large-scale tequila production, diffusers and selected yeasts are common.
4. Distillation
Both tequila and mezcal are distilled twice. The difference lies in the stills: artisanal mezcal uses small-scale copper or clay stills; industrial tequila uses columns and larger equipment.
5. Designation of origin and categories
Both have protected designations of origin, but with different rules. Mezcal is classified as mezcal, artisanal mezcal, or ancestral mezcal, depending on the production method. Tequila is classified mainly by its aging time: blanco, reposado, añejo, and extra añejo. For both, reposado ages for 2 to 12 months in a barrel, and añejo for more than a year.
6. How is each one served and enjoyed?
Mezcal is mainly enjoyed neat, in small sips, in a clay cup or jícara, with a slice of orange and worm salt. Quality tequila is also enjoyed neat, but it is also the base for margaritas and palomas. Mezcal, meanwhile, works very well in smoky versions of the great classics: you will find it in our recipes for cocktails with mezcal.
Which one should you choose?
- If you are looking for something smooth, clean, and easy to mix: a 100% agave tequila.
- If you are looking for character, complexity, and a tasting experience: a mezcal.
- If you want to start with mezcal: an espadín, the most balanced and versatile.
- If you want to explore: a tobalá (floral, wild) or a cuishe (dry, mineral).
- If you are looking for something exceptional: our Capón edition, where the flower stalk is cut and the agave spends another 12 months in the ground.
Frequently asked questions
Is tequila a type of mezcal?
In a broad sense, both are agave spirits, which is why they are referred to as “the mezcal family.” But legally they are two distinct designations, each with its own rules.
Does all mezcal taste smoky?
No. The intensity depends on the agave, the cooking method, and the maestro mezcalero. A tobalá can be much more floral than smoky.
Does mezcal contain a worm?
A worm in the bottle is a marketing convention, not a quality standard, and you will not find it in a serious artisanal mezcal. Worm salt, on the other hand, is a traditional accompaniment.
Which one is stronger?
Both are usually bottled at between 38% and 55% alcohol; it depends on the brand, not the type of drink.
What do you drink with mezcal?
Orange, worm salt, chocolate, aged cheeses, grilled meats, and seafood all pair very well. We have a pairing guide.
Ready to try? Discover our mezcal collection and drink it slowly: slowness and patience.